![]() |
| Home | Contact Us | Careers | Calendar |
|
Maine.gov
> PFR Home
> Insurance Regulation
> Consumer Information
> All Brochures
> Medicare Supplement Insurance 2009
A Consumer's Guide To Medicare Supplement Insurance 2009(comparison chart) A Publication of The Maine Bureau of InsuranceJohn Elias Baldacci Mila Kofman
MEDICARE SUPPLEMENT INSURANCEMedicare Supplement insurance is available from several insurance companies and insurers. These policies cover some of the expenses not paid by Medicare. Medicare Advantage plans and Medicare Part D are not Medicare Supplement coverage. Medicare Advantage plans are offered by companies that contract with Medicare to provide you with all of your Medicare Part A and Part B benefits and some plans cover prescription drugs. For more information on these plans or information on what Medicare does and does not pay, read the Federal booklet, "Choosing a Medigap Policy: A Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare". The booklet is available free from the Maine Bureau of Insurance or your nearest Social Security Administration Office. A more detailed source of information about Medicare is "Medicare & You" available from the Social Security Administration or on-line at www.medicare.gov. Since January 1, 1992, Medicare supplement insurance products have been required to be standardized in Maine. Insurers may sell 10 standard plans plus one high deductible plan which are required to be identified by letter. The plans are labeled: "A", "B", "C", "D", "E", "F", "G", "J", "K", and "L" plans. Plan "F" also has an option called High Deductible Plan F. Companies offering this product are listed in the premium comparison chart. See below for details regarding benefits under the high deductible plan. Plan "A" is the one plan that must be offered by all insurers. Insurers may sell any or all of the other plans. The comparison chart is to help you to compare the policies approved for sale in Maine. Policy benefits are the same for all plans with the same letter. So price and service will be important to think about when you buy a policy. Medicare supplement policies are guaranteed to be renewed each year, as long as you pay the premium. However, the premium may go up each year. All Medicare supplement policies sold in Maine must have a 30-day Free Look period. This means that if for any reason you are not happy with the policy you bought, you can return it to the agent or the insurance company and all money paid will be returned to you. The policy will be treated like it was never issued. CHANGES IN MEDICARE SUPPLEMENT COVERAGE
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Your Current Plan | Replacing Plan | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | B | C | D | E | F | F with high deductible | G | J* | K | L | |
| A | X | X | |||||||||
| B | X | X | X | ||||||||
| C | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |||
| D | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | ||||
| E | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | ||||
| F | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |
| F with a high deductible | X | ||||||||||
| G | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |||
| H* | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |||
| I* | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |
| J* | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X |
| H+ | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |||
| I+ | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |
| J+ | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X |
| K | X | X | |||||||||
| L | X | X | X | ||||||||
+These plans include prescription drug coverage and will not be available after December 31, 2005.
*These plans exclude prescription drug coverage.
The following shows the medical benefits that are covered by your Medicare supplement policy. If you're not sure what Medicare pays, please read the Federal booklet, "Choosing a Medigap Policy: A Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare" which is available free from the Maine Bureau of Insurance, from your nearest Social Security Administration, or at www.medicare.gov. You may be responsible for charges that are not paid by either Medicare or your Medicare supplement policy.
PLAN "A" - Basic Core Benefits
The following are the basic benefits for Plan "A". These benefits are also included in plans "B" through "L".
ADDITIONAL BENEFITS FOUND IN PLANS "B" THROUGH "L"
The following list describes the additional benefits that may be included in plans "B" through "J". The chart shown later in this brochure shows which benefits are included in each plan.
PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS
Some policies will not cover pre-existing medical conditions for the first six months the policy is in effect. A pre-existing medical condition is a condition for which you received medical advice or treatment was recommended by or received from a physician six months before the policy is issued. Even if you buy a Medicare supplement policy during your "open enrollment" period, the policy may still not pay for pre-existing conditions for up to six months. The comparison chart has a column which shows the policies that do not cover pre-existing conditions.
If you had prior health insurance coverage and replace it with a Medicare supplement policy, you cannot be made to satisfy a new pre-existing condition exclusion for similar benefits. This is true whether the prior policy is group coverage through an employer, individual coverage, or another Medicare supplement policy.
The premium comparison chart shows annual premiums. Semi-annual, quarterly and monthly premiums may also be available. These premiums are also subject to change and should be verified with the company or producer for accuracy.
The cost for Medicare supplement policies cannot vary based on your age or gender. Some companies charge a higher rate if you smoke. For these companies, both rates are shown on the chart.
For some companies, the annual premium for Plan C exceeds that for Plan D or E by more than the additional benefit provided. This additional benefit covered by Plan C is the Medicare Part B annual deductible which is $135 in 2009. Therefore, you may want to consider buying Plan D or E instead of Plan C to save money. The company must disclose this rate difference in their outline of coverage when premiums for Plan C exceed Plans D and E.
IMPORTANT! READ THE EXPLANATORY INFORMATION BEFORE USING THIS CHART.
Although we make every effort to provide accurate information, rates may change.
| COMPANY | PRE-EXISTING CONDITION EXCLUSION PERIOD | Plan A | Plan B | Plan C* | Plan D | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
American Network - Penn Treaty |
3 MONTHS | Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $1,953.00 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $1,736.00 |
Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,252.00 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,002.00 |
Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,651.00 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,357.00 |
Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,253.00 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,002.00 |
|
| Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,298.00 Smoker all other zip codes $2,042.00 |
Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,650.00 Smoker all other zip codes $2,355.00 |
Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,119.00 Smoker all other zip codes $2,772.00 |
Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,650.50 Smoker all other zip codes $2,356.00 |
|||
| American Progressive | 3 MONTHS | $2,367.20 | $3,242.52 | $3,908.92 | $3,783.53 | |
| Anthem Blue Cross/Blue Shield | 3 MONTHS | Current | $1,392.36 | $1,754.16 | $2,200.20 | $2,040.12 |
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$1,410.48 | $1,776.96 | $2,228.76 | $2,066.64 | ||
| Bankers Life | NONE | Current | $2,780.38 | $2,823.79 | $3,275.54 | $3,084.52 |
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$2,933.32 | $2,979.14 | $3,455.64 | $3,254.15 | ||
| Combined (Agency) | NONE | $2,131.92 | $2,177.65 | $2,660.67 | Nonsmoker $1,878.51 Smoker $2,170.02 |
|
| Conseco Health | NONE | Current | Nonsmoker $2,076.40 Smoker $2,392.20 |
Nonsmoker $2,895.70 Smoker $3,298.30 |
Nonsmoker $2,755.40 Smoker $3,151.50 |
|
| Effective 4/1/10 |
Nonsmoker $2,076.40 Smoker $2,392.20 |
Nonsmoker $3,185.20 Smoker $3,628.20 |
Nonsmoker $3,031.00 Smoker $3,466.80 |
|||
| Continental General | NONE | $1,784.17 | $1,905.23 | |||
Genworth Life & Annuity Insurance Company |
NONE | Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,569.50 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $1,986.40 |
Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,133.80 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,422.40 |
Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,699.90 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,860.00 |
||
| Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,486.70 Smoker all other zip codes $2,210.40 |
Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,027.60 Smoker all other zip codes $2,691.20 |
Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,575.70 Smoker all other zip codes $3,178.40 |
||||
| Globe Life (Direct Response ) | 6 MONTHS | $958.00 | $1,510.00 | $1,745.00 | ||
| Guarantee Trust Life | 3 MONTHS | $2,188.36 | $2,802.73 | |||
| Humana | 3 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $1,856.76 Smoker $2,561.76 |
Nonsmoker $1,957.44 Smoker $2,936.16 |
Nonsmoker $2,274.00 Smoker $3,396.72 |
||
| Mutual of Omaha | NONE | Nonsmoker $1,620.89 Smoker $1,863.09 |
Nonsmoker $2,672.07 Smoker $3,071.34 |
Nonsmoker $2,448.05 Smoker $2,813.85 |
||
| State Farm | NONE | $1,573.00 | $2,373.00 | |||
| United American | 60 DAYS | Current | $1,793.00 | $2,617.00 | $3,089.00 | $2,960.00 |
| Proposed 1/1/10 |
$1,847.00 | $2,696.00 | $3,182.00 | $3,049.00 | ||
| United HealthCare (for AARP members) |
3 MONTHS | Current | $1,146.00 | $1,638.00 | $1,884.00 | $1,758.00 |
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$1,182.00 | $1,686.00 | $1,944.00 | $1,812.00 | ||
| United Teacher Associates | 6 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $2,444.01 Smoker $3,055.50 |
Nonsmoker $2,936.71 Smoker $3,694.25 |
Nonsmoker $3,308.67 Smoker $4,066.21 |
Nonsmoker $2,938.65 Smoker $3,696.20 |
|
| USAA Life | 6 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $1,505.52 Smoker $1,654.44 |
Nonsmoker $2,023.68 Smoker $2,223.60 |
*See under Cost for an explanation regarding premium differences for Plan C.
| COMPANY | PRE-EXISTING CONDITION EXCLUSION PERIOD | Plan E | Plan F | Plan G | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
American Network - Penn Treaty |
3 MONTHS | Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $2,728.00 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,425.00 |
|||
| Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,208.00 Smoker all other zip codes $2,851.00 |
|||||
| American Progressive | 3 MONTHS | $3,766.99 | $3,967.69 **High Deductible Plan F cost $1,587.65 | $3,775.40 | |
| Anthem Blue Cross/Blue Shield | 3 MONTHS | Current | $2,201.88**High Deductible Plan F cost $783.00 | ||
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$2,230.56**High Deductible Plan F cost $783.00 | ||||
| Bankers Life | NONE | Current | $3,084.52 | $3,301.83**High Deductible Plan F cost $535.85 | $3,093.25 |
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$3,254.15 | $3,483.46 **High Deductible Plan F cost $565.30 | $3,263.43 | ||
| Combined (Agency) | NONE | $2,619.80 | |||
| Conseco Health | NONE | Current | Nonsmoker $2,755.80 Smoker $3,170.80 | Nonsmoker $2,919.10 Smoker $3,322.70 |
Nonsmoker $2,775.70 Smoker $3,155.80 |
| Effective 4/1/10 |
Nonsmoker $3,031.50 Smoker $3,487.90 | Nonsmoker $3,211.10 Smoker $3,655.20 |
Nonsmoker $3,053.30 Smoker $3,471.30 |
||
| Continental General | NONE | $2,086.95 | $1,935.64**High Deductible Plan F cost $599.00 | ||
| Genworth Life & Annuity Insurance Company | NONE | Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,815.10 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,948.80 **High Deductible Plan F Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $1,501.20 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $1,160.00 |
Nonsmoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,230.10 Nonsmoker all other zip codes $2,496.80 |
||
| Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,685.50 Smoker all other zip codes $3,276.00 **High Deductible Plan F Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $1,449.90 Smoker all other zip codes $1,288.80 |
Smoker in zip code beg 039-042, 044 $3,121.20 Smoker all other zip codes $2,774.40 |
||||
| Globe Life (Direct Response) | 6 MONTHS | $1,763.00 | |||
| Guarantee Trust Life | 3 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $2,121.28 Smoker $2,757.66 |
|||
| Humana | 3 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $2,288.40 Smoker $3,425.64 **High Deductible Plan F cost Nonsmoker $906.84 Smoker $1,353.00 | |||
| Mutual of Omaha | NONE | Nonsmoker $2,635.11 Smoker $3,028.86 |
Nonsmoker $1,928.06 Smoker $2,216.16 |
||
| State Farm | NONE | $2,397.00 | |||
| United American | 60 DAYS | Current | $3,148.00 **High Deductible Plan F cost $998.00 | $2,982.00 | |
| Proposed 1/1/10 |
$3,242.00 **High Deductible Plan F cost $998.00 | $3,071.00 | |||
| United HealthCare (AARP) | 3 MONTHS | Current | $1,758.00 | $1,896.00 | $1,770.00 |
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$1,812.00 | $1,956.00 | $1,824.00 | ||
| United Teacher Associates | 6 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $3,322.29 Smoker $4,079.85 |
Nonsmoker $2,948.40 Smoker $3,709.83 |
||
| USAA Life | 6 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $2,060.40 Smoker $2,268.48 |
Nonsmoker $1,995.12 Smoker $2,188.92 |
| COMPANY | PRE-EXISTING CONDITION EXCLUSION PERIOD | New Plan J** | Plan K | Plan L | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Network - Penn Treaty | 3 MONTHS | ||||
| American Progressive | 3 MONTHS | ||||
| Anthem Blue Cross/Blue Shield | 3 MONTHS | Current | $2,208.12 | ||
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$2,236.80 | ||||
| Bankers Life | NONE | Current | $2,365.94 | $1,099.52 | $1,588.02 |
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$2,496.09 | $1,159.95 | $1,675.40 | ||
| Combined (Agency) | NONE | ||||
| Conseco Health | NONE | ||||
| Continental General | NONE | ||||
| Genworth Life & Annuity Insurance Company | NONE | ||||
| Globe Life (Direct Response) | 6 MONTHS | ||||
| Guarantee Trust Life | 3 MONTHS | ||||
| Humana | 3 MONTHS | Nonsmoker $1,093.92 Smoker $1,633.80 |
Nonsmoker $1,587.24 Smoker $2,370.96 |
||
| Mutual of Omaha | NONE | Nonsmoker $1,733.72 Smoker $1,992.78 |
|||
| State Farm | NONE | ||||
| United American | 60 DAYS | Current | $1,519.00 | $2,139.00 | |
| Proposed 1/1/10 |
$1,519.00 | $2,139.00 | |||
| United HealthCare (AARP) | 3 MONTHS | Current | $2,244.00 | $825.00 | $1,176.00 |
| Effective 1/1/10 |
$2,358.00 | $825.00 | $1,176.00 | ||
| United Teacher Associates | 6 MONTHS | ||||
| USAA Life | 6 MONTHS |
+ Available only in Androscoggin, Kennebec, and Penobscot counties.
**No prescription drug benefit.
Note: Fraternal benefit societies differ from insurance companies. They are not covered by some provisions of the Maine Insurance Code and a number of consumer protections. For example, coverage sold by a fraternal is not covered by guaranty funds. In addition, fraternal benefit society insurance benefits are legally required to be assessable. This means that if the society's claims paying ability becomes impaired, the members may be required to pay their proportional share of the deficiency. Fraternal benefit societies are subject to significantly reduced capital and surplus requirements, and are not typically rated by A.M. Best or an equivalent. It is not possible to explain here every aspect in which fraternal benefit societies differ from commercial insurers. For further information contact the Bureau of Insurance at 1-800-300-5000 in Maine.
Proposed rates are those filed by the company but waiting for review and approval by the Bureau. These rates could change before final approval.
Medicare Select policies are also standardized plans, however, to receive full hospital benefits you must use participating hospitals that are in the network. These select policies generally cost less because of restrictions that affect where you can go to get treatment. Review all policy information carefully to be sure that you understand how the provider network limits and restrictions may affect you. If you do not follow the Medicare Select policy requirements, Medicare will still pay its portion of the bill, however, the Medicare Select company is not required to pay the full benefits under the policy and will deny payment or pay less than the full benefit if you go outside the network for non-emergency services. The Medicare Select policies currently available are noted in the premium chart by the word (Select) after the company name. These Medicare Select policies are available only in the following Maine counties: Androscoggin, Kennebec, and Penobscot.
| COMPANY | PRE-EXISTING CONDITION EXCLUSION | Plan A | Plan B | Plan C* | Plan D | Plan E | Plan F | Plan G | Plan J |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
American Progressive |
3 MONTHS | $2,019.21 | $2,498.96 | $2,427.60 | $2,416.97 | $2,514.14 | $2,439.75 |
The chart below shows the guaranteed issue period when you will be accepted in Plan "A" no matter what medical problems you may have.
We have tried to list toll-free numbers where possible. However, not all companies have 800 numbers available and the numbers we have listed are likely to change without notice. You may want to contact a local company producer before calling the numbers listed here. AARP (United Healthcare) sells policies directly and does not use producers.
Medicare Supplement insurance can only be sold in ten standard plans and one high deductible plan - Plan "F". (Please see page 7 for an explanation of the benefits covered in this plan.) The chart below shows the benefits included in each plan. Every company must make Plan "A" available.
| BASIC BENEFITS: | The basic benefits are included in all plans. See the core benefits in this brochure for a listing of the benefits. |
| PLAN A | PLAN B | PLAN C | PLAN D | PLAN E | PLAN F |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic Benefits | Basic Benefits | Basic Benefits | Basic Benefits | Basic Benefits | Basic Benefits |
| Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance | Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance | Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance | Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance | ||
| Part A Deductible | Part A Deductible | Part A Deductible | Part A Deductible | Part A Deductible | |
| Part B Deductible | Part B Deductible | ||||
| Part B Excess (100%) | |||||
| Foreign Travel Emergency | Foreign Travel Emergency | Foreign Travel Emergency | Foreign Travel Emergency | ||
| At-Home Recovery | |||||
| Preventive Care |
| BASIC BENEFITS: | The basic benefits are included in all plans. See the core benefits in this brochure for a listing of the benefits. |
| PLAN G | PLAN J | PLAN K* | PLAN L* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic Benefits | Basic Benefits | 50% Basic Benefits except 100% Part A Co-insurance | 75% Basic Benefits except 100% Part A Co-insurance |
| Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance | Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance | 50% Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance | 75% Skilled Nursing Co-Insurance |
| Part A Deductible | Part A Deductible | 50% Part A Deductible | 75% Part A Deductible |
| Part B Deductible | |||
| Part B Excess (80%) | Part B Excess (100%) | ||
| Foreign Travel Emergency | Foreign Travel Emergency | ||
| At-Home Recovery | At-Home Recovery | ||
| Preventive Care |
*Plans K and L provide for different cost-sharing for items and services than Plans A through J. Once you reach the annual limit ($4,620 for Plan K and $2,310 for Plan L in 2009), the plans pays 100% of the Medicare co-payments, coinsurance, and deductibles for the rest of the calendar year. The out-of-pocket annual limit does NOT include charges from your provider that exceed Medicare-approved amounts, called "Excess Charges." You will be responsible for paying excess charges. The out-of-pocket annual limit will increase each year for inflation.
MEDICARE and MAINECARE ELIGIBLE?
THINGS TO CONSIDER ABOUT MEDIGAP COVERAGE WHEN YOU ENROLL IN MAINECARE
Area agencies on Aging are the central resource for elder services in your area. they can help you either directly or by referring you to the appropriate agency. Call Elders 1 at 1-877-353-3771 to contact the Area Agency on Aging in your area.
AROOSTOOK AREA AGENCY ON AGING
AROOSTOOK COUNTY
P.O. Box 1288, 33 Davis Street
Presque Isle, ME 04769
TEL: (207) 764-3396;1-800-439-1789
www.aroostookaging.org
EASTERN AREA AGENCY ON AGING
PENOBSCOT, PISCATAQUIS, HANCOCK
WASHINGTON COUNTIES
450 Essex St.
Bangor, ME 04401
TEL: (207) 941-2865; 1-800-432-7812
www.eaaa.org
SPECTRUM GENERATIONS
KNOX, LINCOLN, WALDO, SOMERSET,
SAGADAHOC, KENNEBEC COUNTIES
TOWNS OF BRUNSWICK AND HARPSWELL
1 Weston Court PO Box 2589
Augusta, ME 04338-2589
TEL: (207) 622-9212; 1-800-639-1553
www.seniorspectrum.com
SENIORSPLUS
ANDROSCOGGIN, FRANKLIN, OXFORD COUNTIES
P.O. Box 659, 8 Falcon Way.
Lewiston, ME 04243-0659
TEL: (207) 795-4010; 1-800-427-1241
www.seniorsplus.org
SOUTHERN MAINE AREA AGENCY ON AGING
CUMBERLAND and YORK COUNTIES
136 US Route One.
Scarborough, ME 04074
TEL: (207) 396-6500; 1-800-427-7411
www.smaaa.org
Since 1870, the Bureau of Insurance has overseen and regulated the business activities of insurance companies, producers and adjusters in our state.
To ensure that the marketing of insurance is lawful and honest, policies and premiums are reasonable and just, and the payment of legitimate claims is dependable and timely, the Bureau is organized into the following work units: Property and Casualty, Consumer Health Care, Life and Disability, Market Conduct, Legal, Examination, Financial Analysis, Self-Insurance, Workers’ Compensation, Licensing and Administration.
Other publications are available through:
The Bureau of Insurance
34 State House Station
Augusta, ME 04333
(207) 624-8475
(800) 300-5000 (Maine only)
For other information and consumer brochures visit our Internet
page at:
www.maine.gov/insurance
Last Updated: November 18, 2009
| Copyright © 2006 All rights reserved. |